Thursday, December 17, 2009
Times-Pic Publishes Juvenile's Name: Ethical?
Posted by David Winkler-Schmit on Thu, Dec 17, 2009 at 8:44 PM
If you were startled to see the 14-year-old murder suspect’s name published in today’s The Times-Picayune, surrounding the murder of United Cab Co. driver Mahyar Kasravi, you weren’t alone. On the night of Dec. 8, Kasravi, 59, was shot and killed during an apparent botched robbery. Quintina Tolbert, 23, and two teenage boys have been arrested in the case.
- “I was really shocked to see The Times-Picayune come out with a juvenile’s name like that,” New Orleans Police Department spokesman Bob Young says, adding that NOPD cannot legally release the names of juvenile suspects unless they are charged as adults by the district attorney’s office. In this case, the suspect has been arrested and is currently being held in the juvenile facility, but has not yet been charged.
- Ramon Antonio Vargas, the TP staff writer who reported the story, says he obtained the suspect’s name during a public hearing in juvenile court, where Judge David Bell found there was probable cause to arrest all three suspects.
- “If it’s in an open hearing and they’re identified there,” Vargas says, “then we do run the names.” Although that is the paper’s policy, it’s not a decision the TP takes lightly. Before the story ran, Vargas says he discussed the issue with Jim Amoss, the TP editor. According to the Louisiana Children’s Code, juvenile court proceedings are open to the public when it involves a violent crime.
- Eden Heilman, a staff attorney with the Southern Poverty Law Center who has represented a number of juvenile defendants, says it is legal to publish the names of juvenile suspects. She also says, however, that juvenile court proceedings are supposed to be sealed and sentences are geared towards rehabilitating suspects as opposed to punishing them. If this particular suspect’s case remains in juvenile court, then Heilman feels publishing the boy’s name is a problem.
- “He now has a very public label on his back,” Heilman says.
- As for NOPD’s “shock,” at the TP’s publishing the name, Vargas is surprised by that reaction.
“I don’t why,” Vargas says. “It’s not the first time we’ve identified a juvenile murder suspect.”
- So what do you think? Should the local media identify juvenile suspects that are accused of violent crimes? Does it matter if the suspect is charged in juvenile court or adult court?
Speaking of...
-
On the television show Homicide, this was called a "red ball"
The FBI is assisting in the Good Samaritan murder investigation.
- Jan 26, 2012
-
Another week, another front-page murder...
Judges asked to increase bonds for gun defendants, require electronic monitoring.
- Jan 25, 2012
-
Philly mayor has unique diagnosis for curbing his city's murder problem
After three 14-year-olds are gunned down, Philadelphia mayor Michael Nutter urges citizens "not to act like idiots and assholes." Sounds good to us.
- Jan 13, 2012
- More »
Comments (5)
Showing 1-5 of 5
What does it say about me that I read your subject heading and thought you were talking about rappers?
like
dislike
Why is this even a debate? The kid admitted to making the phone call that incited the crime. Maybe he didn't pull the trigger, but he's still an accomplice and, therefore, a criminal. Anyone could have walked into that courtroom; so what if the TP covered the story? I'm glad to know the [alleged] culprits are off the street. Also, I agree with Mr. Vargas in terms of being surprised by anyone else's surprise. All three of the people involved in the shooting of Wendy Byrne were juveniles, and their names were released. If a first degree murder has been committed, the protection of being under 18 is waived. Finally, proofread. I don't care if you're a measly blogger, but I do care if you misquote someone.
Hi What's the point of this?, What was misquoted? And how would you know if someone was misquoted? - A Measly Blogger
“I don’t why,” Vargas says... It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that Mr. Vargas meant "I don't KNOW why." That's why I said "proofread" instead of "Get your story straight."
Thanks, Mr. What's the point of this? I'll make the correction when I'm at work tomorrow. As for the point, this was a presentation of what went behind publishing a juvenile suspect's name in a newspaper, and some differing opinions regarding it. In general, making public juveniles' names has been the subject of more than one court case. Ms. Heilman had a point in terms of rehabilitation; The TP has a policy (that it seems they take seriously, but question on a case-by-case basis; and you, with the strength of anonymous conviction, have yours as well. Thanks for reading.
