The Louisiana Senate struck down a bill that would repeal unconstitutional language in The Balanced Treatment for Creation-Science and Evolution-Science Act, which was adopted in 1981 but ruled unconstitutional by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1987. Despite the ruling, the unenforceable act remains on the books. As a matter of formality, Sen. Dan Claitor, R-Baton Rouge, proposed Senate Bill 70 — which made it through committee earlier this month — which would repeal the language in the law. With only five yea votes, the bill failed to pass. Claitor said he will bring it up for a second vote.
The law will continue to state that "public schools within this state shall give balanced treatment to creation-science and to evolution-science. ... When creation or evolution is taught, each shall be taught as a theory, rather than as proven scientific fact." It also says schools cannot "discriminate by reducing a grade of a student or by singling out and publicly criticizing any student who demonstrates a satisfactory understanding of both evolution-science or creation-science and who accepts or rejects either model in whole or part."