It took Rothfeder more than three years to tell his version of the McIlhennys' story. 'This is my sixth book, and I thought from past experience I would be able to get it done a lot more quickly," he says in a phone interview. 'But it was a harder book to write than I expected, maybe because of the McIlhennys being pretty secretive. So not having access to the material and access to the top people on the record added a level of difficulty which meant I had to open up new sources."
Rothfeder has had lots of experience in tracking down sources during his career. In addition to writing a half-dozen books, he is a former news editor with BusinessWeek, TIME and Bloomberg News. He also has written for The New York Times and The Washington Post. He's appeared on 20/20, Nightline, Today, Good Morning America and Oprah. His books include Every Drop for Sale: Our Desperate Battle Over Water and Privacy for Sale: How Computerization Has Made Everyone's Private Life an Open Secret.
For McIlhenny's Gold, Rothfeder relied on some 50 interviews he conducted as well as academic papers and past newspaper and magazine articles.
'Most were written favorably to the family," he says. 'They tended to be puff pieces, but I could pull out certain information I needed. I just basically found everything I could.
'I definitely got the most information on them than anyone's ever been able to produce. There's been a couple other books that have mentioned the McIlhennys over the years, but this is really the only one that tells the story of the family."
Shane Bernard's company-sanctioned book, Tabasco: An Illustrative History, relies on primary source documents from the family and the company's archives. According to Bernard, it's completely coincidental that in the company's 140 years of operation, two books focused on the history of the family, the company and Tabasco sauce are being released within a month of each other.
'I know it's hard to believe," he says, 'but it is (coincidental). I certainly wouldn't have wanted it that way."
McIlhenny Co. is self-publishing Bernard's book, but the author says the company had no hand in editing any of the history in the manuscript.
'I was pleasantly surprised at how much I was able to write," he says. 'For example, the NASCAR Team Tabasco incident is not one that's been remembered here very pleasantly. The race car was beautiful and everything " we had great drivers, Todd Bodine and Darrell Waltrip " but it just didn't go anywhere. We never won any races. It was a fiasco. But I mentioned it, and nobody said anything."
In McIlhenny's Gold, Rothfeder paints Bernard as a McIlhenny hired gun charged with the duties of a public relations flack. He contends that Bernard was ordered by the family to whitewash the story that Edward Avery McIlhenny (son of Tabasco founder Edmund) was responsible for unleashing the destructive scourge of the nutria on south Louisiana. But in a 2002 issue of Louisiana History, Bernard directly addressed McIlhenny's involvement with the nutria: '... while McIlhenny purposely released a small number of nutria in 1940 and a substantially larger number by late 1945, he was neither the first nor even the second nutria farmer in Louisiana; nor was he the first in the state to set loose the animals intentionally; nor did he import them from Argentina " all claims that were previously accepted as indisputable and, like nutria themselves, proliferated wildly."
Rothfeder finds it strange that McIlhenny Co. would even hire a full-time archivist, especially considering the company's small size of only 200 people. 'What it says to you, I believe, is that it's a company that wants to protect their history, or protect their telling of the story. Look, as I tell in the book, the job [Bernard] was working on when I first met him was trying to clean up the nutria story so that "Mr. Ned' [McIlhenny] wasn't saddled with being the one who introduced nutria to Louisiana.
'The fact is he really did. There may have been nutria around as well from others, but he was the one who really introduced it to Louisiana, and there's no way around that. But ... you put a guy on payroll to clean up that story. That's kind of an interesting thing to me, and something certainly that most other companies wouldn't do."
Bernard, on the other hand, points out that it's not unusual for companies with 'iconic status" " like The Walt Disney Co. and Harley-Davidson " to hire historians. He started working for McIlhenny Co. in 1993 on what was supposed to be a six-month stint to research the life of John Avery McIlhenny, another son of Edmund's who was a former Rough Rider and friend of Teddy Roosevelt.
'We have a lot of papers and letters and documents that the family kept, and they were in disarray," says Paul McIlhenny. '[Bernard]'s debunked some of the family myths, and those that he doesn't know, he's perfectly honest about."
Bernard's previous books include Swamp Pop: Cajun and Creole Rhythm and Blues and The Cajuns: Americanization of a People. The research he conducted for McIlhenny Co. has found its way into his new book, which was to be a companion piece for a Tabasco museum that was slated to open in New Orleans but was scrapped after Hurricane Katrina.
The details of Tabasco's history vary widely in Bernard's and Rothfeder's books, and the conclusions paint two different portraits of a family and its famous, fiery pepper sauce.
McIlhenny's Gold begins with the old myth of how Tabasco founder Edmund McIlhenny acquired the seeds for his peppers and his Tabasco sauce from a Confederate soldier named Friend Gleason early in the Civil War. McIlhenny planted the seeds and then fled Avery Island with his family in advance of a Union incursion. When he returned after the war, he found the peppers still growing in the rubble of his former life. Those peppers would make the first batches of what was to become Tabasco pepper sauce. In McIlhenny's Gold, Rothfeder writes: 'This desire to sugarcoat the truth is a recurring motif in the story of McIlhenny Co. The family has historically relied on half-lies and legend to embellish the image of its pepper sauce, generate increased sales, eliminate rivals and adorn the McIlhenny myth in southern Louisiana."
'Until recently," Bernard writes in his book, 'mythology obscured much of the history of Tabasco sauce and the early McIlhenny family." He says the family legend has Gleason as a veteran of the Mexican-American War, but that either way, the 'account is largely untrue," and how McIlhenny acquired his peppers remains a mystery.
'It would be difficult to find another company so mysterious (and uncertain) about the genesis of its flagship product," writes Rothfeder. 'But then McIlhenny Co., one of the most profitable and oldest family businesses in U.S. history, has made a habit of being out of sync with the rest of corporate America. [T]he company (and the family) has remained anonymous, while its product, Tabasco sauce, has taken its place among the best-known brands in the world, a category killer whose name is the market classification, like globe-straddling goliaths Coke, Kodak and Kleenex."
Rothfeder estimates that McIlhenny Co. is a $250 million-a-year family business (including royalties from product licensing and oil and salt on its land) that cranks out 600,000 bottles of Tabasco sauce every day for distribution in 120 countries.
Rothfeder contends that Edmund McIlhenny didn't even invent Tabasco sauce and points to Maunsel White's Concentrated Essence of Tabasco Peppers, a predecessor to McIlhenny's sauce. 'Although the McIlhennys have tried to dismiss the possibility," writes Rothfeder, 'it seems clear now that in 1849, a full two decades before Edmund McIlhenny professed to discover the Tabasco pepper, White was already growing Tabasco chilies on his plantation."
Bernard counters that it's been proven that the two men used different techniques " White cooked his peppers and McIlhenny fermented his " to make their sauces and that White's family sold and marketed his product to the public only after his death in 1863. White was making his sauce before McIlhenny sold his first batch in 1869 from the previous year's crop of peppers, but Bernard says, 'Whether or not the peppers are the same, nobody knows."
There are specific product names " like Kleenex, Xerox and even Dumpster " that have become part of our lexicon and have come to be understood in general terms, such as Q-Tip being used instead of the generic cotton swab. But the name 'Tabasco" is unique in that it was a general name that's now recognized by the federal government as a specific product that describes McIlhenny Co.'s pepper sauce.
The word originates from the Tabasco region of Mexico from where the peppers are thought to have come. Bernard says his research indicates that during Edmund McIlhenny's day, the word was used rather loosely. In 1906, with a federal trademark law recently established, McIlhenny registered 'Tabasco" as a trademark with the U.S. Patent Office. 'So between 1868 and 1906, our lawyers contended, ultimately successfully, that the term Tabasco had acquired a secondary meaning in the marketplace that was associated largely with McIlhenny Co.," Bernard says, 'and that it wasn't until a few years earlier, around 1900, that a number of imitators popped up. That's how we were able to claim that trademark."
Rothfeder writes that when McIlhenny Co. applied for the trademark, it falsely claimed that no other product contained the name Tabasco, even though there actually were a dozen products on the market that had used the word. B.F. Trappey, a former blacksmith for McIlhenny who made his own Tabasco sauce, raised such a ruckus about the trademark that the patent office rescinded it three years later. But in 1918, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit overruled the trademark office and gave McIlhenny the sole use of the name again.
According to Rothfeder's book, the court overlooked McIlhenny's fabrication and the evidence presented by Trappey (that Maunsel White had originated the sauce) and instead chose to rely on the myth of Friend Gleason as evidence. Trappey fought the decision for the next 30 years but ultimately lost. Rothfeder writes that since the decision, the McIlhennys have vigorously protected their trademark and threatened lawsuits, when necessary, to protect it.
Bernard is aware that there are people who don't believe McIlhenny Co. should have the legal right to the name Tabasco. 'But you have 109 years of litigation that say otherwise," he says. 'There were a few cases in the early days in which we did not prevail, but by around 1920, the last of those difficult cases was over with, and since then, it's all simply been a matter of precedent. On one hand, you can continue to argue about the subject, but federal judges for the past at least 80-plus years beg to differ."
Rothfeder hasn't heard a word from McIlhenny Co. about his book. 'It's a little surprising," he says, 'because as you know, the way they protect their trademark is that they threaten to sue anybody that touches the word Tabasco."
Rothfeder is no stranger to the courtroom or to controversy. In 1998, a federal judge ruled that the writer had fraudulently obtained information from a credit reporting agency for a 1989 news story but denied any punitive damages, ruling that his work was in the public's interest.
That same year, Rothfeder made headlines in two other incidents. The New York Observer wrote that tension was at an all-time high for three Bloomberg reporters who penned the book The People Vs. Big Tobacco: 'After busting their tails to crank out the in-house book in record time with little financial incentive, Bloomberg sources say that the three reporters have had to sit back and watch as their bigfooting boss, Jeffrey Rothfeder, the head of Bloomberg's national news desk, has taken the lion's share of the credit."
After leaving Bloomberg, Rothfeder was set to be managing editor of CNBC when, The Washington Post reported, 'things hit a little snag." According to the Post story, Rothfeder had incorrectly stated on his résumé that he earned a degree from the University of California at Berkeley. Rothfeder, however, told the Post he had never claimed to be a Berkeley graduate on his résumé and was a victim of a rumor campaign. He didn't take the new job, and two years later he dismissed the Post's story as being based on anonymous sources. 'Nobody pays any attention to that," he told the San Francisco Chronicle.
When asked about where he obtained the annual revenue figure of $250 million for the private McIlhenny Co., Rothfeder would only say, 'Two or three different sources who know their books pretty well." If Rothfeder had a problem with anonymous sources in the past, he had resolved them for McIlhenny's Gold. He writes, 'Some of the people I interviewed are quoted in the book; others asked that their names not be used because they did not want to anger the extremely guarded Avery Island McIlhennys, who formally declined to participate in the project."
By the end of his book, Rothfeder paints a portrait of a lucrative family-owned company at a crossroads, faced with the options of either holding on to the traditional ways of doing business and dying off or embracing new possibilities in order to survive. 'They're going to have to become less inbred and less insular, have some outside management come in and do a real close look at what they're doing, do some soul-searching, and maybe they can come out of this OK," he says. The McIlhenny Co.'s last attempt to become 'less inbred and less insular" didn't go so well, Rothfeder says. It's what Bernard has referred to as the 'NASCAR Team Tabasco incident."
During the late '90s, Rothfeder writes, Vince Pierse, the only nonfamily member in the company's history, was named McIlhenny Co.'s chief executive. During his tenure, Pierse mounted an aggressive and expensive marketing campaign to build the Tabasco brand, including an annual $15 million sponsorship of a NASCAR racing team. Rothfeder believes Pierse was sacked before his ideas to reinvigorate Tabasco could take root and that it was the first real opportunity the company allowed itself to bring in fresh ideas from outside the McIlhenny bloodline.
Of this period Bernard writes: 'Following a short-lived experiment with the only nonfamily president in the company's history " an interregnum that witnessed an unsuccessful NASCAR® Winston Cup racing endeavor called Team TABASCO " Paul C.P. McIlhenny assumed the presidency of McIlhenny Co. in 1998 and two years later became its CEO."
Paul McIlhenny won't comment on Rothfeder's accusations, but it's apparent that it is a time in the company's history that still irks him.
'Vince was never our CEO," he says. 'I think Vince's title was chief operating officer, but he was never chief executive officer. So yeah, he would have been involved in many things, in marketing as well as NASCAR. I'm the current president and CEO, and Ned McIlhenny Simmons was president and CEO before me. So all of the chief executive officers in McIlhenny Co. have been family members."
There now is increasing competition from within the niche market of pepper products, Rothfeder contends, and cheaper brands are cutting into Tabasco's market share. Add to that a declining profit margin, rising costs and more dividends to pay out to more heirs of Edmund McIlhenny, and McIlhenny Co. has a real problem on its hands, he surmises.
'They're in a lot of trouble at this point, and I don't know the way out for them," Rothfeder says. 'Their great business model and their belief in their past has now put them in a bind, and that combination of things will make a difficult future for them. The good news is they could sell their company to Kraft or Campbell's or whomever and get $2 billion for it, and that's a lot of money. They could share the money and walk away."
McIlhenny's CEO doesn't appear ready to take that step any time soon. He points to the six flavors of Tabasco, co-branding with other national food products, royalties on the branding of slot machines, licensing the brand for an online and catalog business as well as the Tabasco Country Stores on Avery Island and in New Orleans. 'Our brand share has remained solid, if not grown, the last few years," he says. 'We're very pleased with our marketing allocation and our marketing programs and our new products."
Paul McIlhenny estimates that 20 percent of the company's business is derived from outside the pepper sauce lines. 'Over half of our business is in the restaurant segment nationally," he says. 'That's very important, and our franchise has grown there as well in the last few years, particularly where consumers ask for the product at the table. We're also in the kitchen where the chef uses it. So to me, our growth in revenues, our growth in profits, our growth in dividends, our growth in marketing budget to support the brand are all signs of vibrancy and solidity."
When it comes to the dueling books about the company, Rothfeder says there is no real competition. 'The reason their book is coming out is because of my book," he says of Bernard's tome. 'That's my opinion, but they didn't tell me that. Look, they're self-publishing it, so I'm not concerned about that book from the perspective of the real world of book publishing, meaning that no one's going to review their book since they're self-publishing it. And it's not really competition because it's like 40-something dollars, and it looks like it's going to be more like a coffee table book. And the history is going to be what the company wants the history to be. But I certainly feel that they're coming out with a book because of my book, because they want to steal some of the thunder from that."
Paul McIlhenny won't comment on Rothfeder's book. 'We told [Rothfeder] we weren't going to approve his manuscript or read it, and we haven't," he says. 'So I'm just loath to comment on it after the fact, because he didn't have the resources that [Bernard] had. There may be some personal umbrages taken, but I think the mystique of Avery Island and the brand is strong enough to survive an unauthorized version and hopefully is made stronger by [Bernard]'s effort."
R. Reese Fuller is managing editor of The Independent Weekly in Lafayette, where this story originally appeared.