Pin It
Favorite

Mary's Media Bias 

U.S. Sen. Mary Landrieu is pushing two press-friendly bills through Congress, but she swears it's all about protecting the Fourth Estate, not currying its favor.

Parking was extremely limited at the emergency operations center in Baton Rouge. Print reporters and media vans were forced to make their own spots in nearby median strips or grassy fields. Roughly 24 hours had passed since Katrina officially made landfall, and her rain and wind could still be felt farther up Interstate 10. Moisture is technology's archenemy, so broadcast news crews hurriedly made makeshift tents out of tarps while their interns clung to cups of coffee for the on-air personalities.

Information was scarce during those early hours, and the appearance of Mary Landrieu, Louisiana's senior U.S. senator and a New Orleans native, sent the pack scurrying. She was drenched and visibly weary, having replaced her business suit with a work shirt some time ago. After a few interviews providing nothing of substance for the 24-hour cycle, Landrieu slipped inside headquarters to deal with what was surely another storm of data and desperation.

A few hours later, she emerged and headed directly for a handful of print journalists on the clock for national publications. "This is off the record," she says, her voice shaking. The rest of the conversation came in pieces as reporters, allowing their natural instincts to take hold, approached the impromptu gathering. Every time it happened, Landrieu would grab her chosen few and pull them into further seclusion.

"This thing is serious," she carried on. "You have no idea yet, but it is. We're going to need a lot of coverage for a very long time. There is a human side to this story, too. It's like nothing we've ever seen before."

Today, Landrieu doesn't mind placing the tale into public record. After all, it offers an inside look at how a seasoned politico can work the right media outlets when the entire world is watching -- literally. It's also a practical example of how information is often filtered to the public during times of disaster. Either way, the background is a fitting description of Landrieu, especially now as she pushes two media-friendly bills through Congress.

She is a primary co-sponsor of a bill filed last week that would set a federal standard for protecting journalists and their confidential sources. It's called the Free Flow of Information Act and stipulates that a confidential source can only be handed over to prevent "imminent and actual harm" to national security or a real person. The proposed act also protects information that might reveal a source, such as phone records. It's a major issue for national media outlets, whose membership is being pulled into court on a regular basis, most notably over the leaked name of an agent for the Central Intelligence Agency whose name allegedly was leaked by someone in the Bush Administration.

Compelling reporters to testify and reveal where their scoop originated will restrict the flow of information to the public, says Richard Karpel, executive director of the Association of Alternative Newsweeklies, one of the 40 media companies and journalistic organizations backing the proposal. "When the news is bad, it's only natural that public officials try to hide it," Karpel says. "Consequently, confidential sources are often the only means to uncovering the truth. By protecting those sources, this bill helps the American public hold its government accountable."

While 32 states, including Louisiana, have so-called shield laws on the books protecting reporters and their sources to various degrees, there is no uniform standard in federal courts. Landrieu says reporters' freedoms must be protected universally. "Open government is a tenet of our democracy," she says. "The revelation (that) the Bush Administration turned away nearly $1 billion in foreign aid after Hurricane Katrina came to light as the result of the (Freedom of Information Act) process and demonstrates its essential function as a public check on government power and policy."

Landrieu's other media bill, which she is solely responsible for drafting, was released earlier this year and could ultimately clear some of the hurdles the broadcast media and others face when covering a natural disaster. For starters, the First Response Broadcasters Act states that the local agency in charge of media credentials will remain in charge even after a disaster strikes and the Federal Emergency Management Agency shows up, thus preventing journalists from applying twice for the same official credentials.

This bill also opens up access for local broadcasters to federal gas, food and water supplies during a natural disaster. In the aftermath of Katrina, Landrieu says local broadcasters on the ground lost out on fuel and other supplies procured by out-of-state media outlets. She is also pushing a grant program to help broadcasters protect and upgrade their facilities. "With phone lines down, cell phones out and streets flooded, the sound of local radio and television stations was what many people relied on," she says. "It was an important voice in those dark days and nights following the storm and flooding, and that voice continued on for months."

Even in north Louisiana, where tornadoes and floods can devastate communities, Landrieu says the legislation will have an impact. The American Society of Newspaper Editors, however, has expressed displeasure over the lack of attention given to print journalists. Landrieu's camp responds that emergencies demand immediacy, which means electronics. The National Association of Broadcasters, along with the Radio-Television News Directors Association, has endorsed the bill. "The ability of radio and television stations and their online components to broadcast with minimal interruptions before, during and after a disaster is an absolute necessity, and we think this legislation will address many of their needs," says RTNDA president Barbara Cochran.

Public approval -- the gold standard in politics -- has traditionally been low for the media, especially when it comes to matters of trust. So, why would Landrieu, who is facing re-election next year, stick her neck out for the other branch of government? Is she hoping for a free ride? "No, that is not the reason," says Stephanie Allen, Landrieu's press secretary. "I know Sen. Landrieu well and she is under no illusion that co-sponsoring these bills will prompt the press to cover her more favorably. Actually, sometimes just the opposite is true. She is just a huge supporter of the freedom of the press."

Jeremy Alford can be reached at jeremy@jeremyalford.com.

click to enlarge "The revelation (that) the Bush Administration turned - away nearly $1 billion in foreign aid after Hurricane - Katrina came to light as the result of the (Freedom of - Information Act) process and demonstrates its essential - function as a public check on government power and - policy." - U.S. Sen. Mary Landrieu - U.S. SENATE PHOTOGRAPHER
  • U.S. Senate Photographer
  • "The revelation (that) the Bush Administration turned away nearly $1 billion in foreign aid after Hurricane Katrina came to light as the result of the (Freedom of Information Act) process and demonstrates its essential function as a public check on government power and policy." U.S. Sen. Mary Landrieu
Pin It
Favorite

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Submit an event Jump to date

Latest in News

More by Jeremy Alford

Spotlight Events

  • St. Claude Second Saturdays @ St. Claude Arts District
    2820 St. Claude Ave.

    • Second Saturday of every month
    • 4 going/interested

© 2016 Gambit
Powered by Foundation